Shelter Island, New York

Click for Shelter Island, NY Forecast

Shelter Island, New York, USA

Lodging in Shelter Island, New York

Hotels, Lodges, Extended Stay

  • Sunset Beach
    35 Shore Road, Shelter Island, NY 11965
    631-749-2001, Luxury boutique hotel on Long Island that features beach front accommodations and stylish amenities. This beach hotel in Shelter Island, NY also features an... more info

Bed & Breakfast, Cabins & Cottages

  • Shelter Island, NY, on VRBO┬«
    Renting a private vacation home offers the affordability, exceptional value, and personal attention that you deserve. Most private vacation homes offer considerably more space than you will find in the typical hotel room often at a reduced cost. Now, families can vacation together and still have room to breathe. View their list of vacation rentals now...

  • Olde Country Inn
    11 Stearns Point Road; P.O. Box 1209, Shelter Island, NY 11965
    631-749-1633, Nestled between the North and South Forks of Long Island, New York, this charming Victorian Inn is located on beautiful Shelter Island in the historic district of the... more info  map

Lodging Guides and Directories

  • BedandBreakfast.com
    is a leading directory of bed and breakfasts, inns, and boutique lodgings throughout neighboring New York towns. Shop, compare, and book from their large selection of B&B properties with many exclusive deals offered. Gift certificates are also available. BedandBreakfast.com has nearly 7,000 property listings throughout the United States with 50,000 reviews, 80,000 property photos, and interactive maps.

Condos & Vacation Rentals

  • Shelter Island, NY,Vacation Rentals By Owner on VRBO%uFFFD
    Renting a private vacation home offers the affordability, exceptional value, and personal attention that you deserve. Most private vacation homes offer considerably more space than you will find in the typical hotel room often at a reduced cost. Now, families can vacation together and still have room to breathe. View their list of vacation rentals now...

  • HomeAway Vacation Rentals in Shelter Island, NY
    Forget ordinary hotel rooms! Finding the perfect vacation getaway in Shelter Island, NY is easy on HomeAway.com. Choose from 75,000 homes, condos, guesthouses, cottages, and cabins worldwide, and inquire directly with property owners through the site. HomeAway.com vacation rentals offer a unique local experience, often less expensive and more spacious than hotel rooms.

  • Pridwin Beach Hotel & Cottages, The
    P.O. Box 2009, Shelter Island, NY 11964
    631-749-0476, Near the 2,000-acre Mashomack Nature Preserve, the Pridwin Hotel on Crescent Beach has 40 rooms with waterview, without waterview and partial waterview. All rooms come... more info

  

Lodging in Shelter Island

Towns Near Shelter Island